A fireplace mantel has the power to completely change the mood of a room—whether or not you actually have a working fireplace. Recently, home decor enthusiast Michelle Hsu gave her faux mantel the cutest refresh, and her clever trick is one you’ll want to try immediately.

Instead of leaving the inside of her faux mantel empty, Michelle added peel-and-stick tiles in a chic black-and-white check pattern. The twist? She didn’t apply them directly to the wall. Instead, she placed them on poster board, which she can easily slide in and out whenever she’s ready for a new look. Talk about budget-friendly flexibility!

Where to Get a Faux Fireplace Mantel

Michelle originally purchased her faux mantel from Wayfair about four years ago. While that exact style is no longer available, we found a two gorgeous alternatives:

• Berthine Ornate Decorative Fireplace Mantel – Wayfair ($999.99)
• Ashley Furniture Decorative Fireplace Mantel ($554.99)

These options give you that timeless fireplace look without the hassle of an installation.

Shop the Mantel Makeover

If you’re feeling inspired to create your own mantel refresh, here are the exact or similar pieces Michelle used to achieve her stylish look:

• Peel & Stick Tiles – Amazon, $37.99
• Electric Candle Sticks – Amazon
• Rug – Handwoven Rectangle Scalloped Jute Rug, Pottery Barn
• Similar Wall Paint Color – Benjamin Moore Rose Accent 1177

Michelle’s mantel decor layers perfectly with her beautiful small gallery wall above a cozy green round armchair, adding charm and personality to the entire corner of the room.

Why This DIY Mantel Makeover Works

✔️ Budget-Friendly
✔️ Rental-Friendly: Since the tiles are applied to poster board, there’s no damage to the wall.
✔️ Easily Customizable: Slide it out and swap for a new design whenever inspiration strikes.
✔️ Designer Look for Less: By mixing high/low pieces (like a Pottery Barn rug with Amazon finds), Michelle created a chic yet approachable vibe.

Final Thoughts

A faux fireplace mantel doesn’t have to feel empty or unfinished. With a little creativity—and some affordable peel & stick tiles—you can turn yours into a stylish focal point that elevates your entire living space.

Would you try this DIY Mantel Makeover Hack in your home? For more inspiration: Best Built-In BookShelves Around A Fireplace Design Ideas